Thursday, 15 March 2012

Creating a Wiki – Reflection

My experience of using a wiki is now twofold!  I have been a member of a wiki, the mobile phones wiki, and then today, I created my own wiki – so now I am the ‘organiser’ of a wiki – I feel so important!  Click here to check it out.  So now I’m going to reflect on the learning potential of a wiki, considering the technical affordances of a wiki, and how these can be used to support, facilitate and transform learning (great scaffolding Wendy!).
Strengths:
·         Learner-centred
·         Part of Web 2.0, the “read-write” web
·         Can include links to websites, YouTube, photographs, video, audio & more
·         Supports brainstorming well, “messy” to reflect real-life learning
·         Can be edited by users and guests
·         Everybody can contribute, but nobody has to
·         Teachers can scaffold the activity so that students are guided to demonstrate the required learning
·         Promotes higher-order thinking skills
·         Supports the productive pedagogies, TPACK, & Bloom’s taxonomy, when scaffolded effectively
·         Each student can work on it when it suits them; they don’t all have to be in the same room at the same time.
Weaknesses:
·         It is easy to remove, overwrite, or edit the work of another
·         If 2 or more people are editing a wiki at the same time, only the work of one will be saved.
·         Good scaffolding is critical
Opportunities:
·         Contributions can be recovered if someone realises that work has been inadvertently edited
·         Great for collaborating and sharing ideas
·         It is public so students may be encouraged to try harder – don’t want to appear incompetent – an authentic audience, and more ‘real’
·         Great for reflection if scaffolded appropriately– this promotes analytical, evaluation, and synthesis skills
·         Very valuable constructivist learning tool
·         Supports connectivism

Threats:
·         Ethics & on-line safety must always be observed
·         Google docs is a better space for 2 or more people to work on a document concurrently

Scaffolding is the key to a successful wiki.  De Bono’s hats were used in the mobile phones wiki in Week 2 and proved to be an excellent tool for extracting people’s opinions and knowledge as they considered the issue from different viewpoints.  The greatest strength of a wiki appears to be as a tool for group work - students can collaborate and refine ideas.  Once again the opportunities for use in a classroom are only limited to the imagination, from keeping a list of class members contact details , to ‘brainstorming’, to a place to dissect and review exam questions, to solving a complex math problem together.  The list really is endless.  Good scaffolding is essential so that the students using the wiki stay focused and the desired learning outcomes eventuate.

The possibility of deleting other student contributions is an important consideration in deciding if a wiki is the best tool to utilise.  It requires a certain amount of trust amongst the wiki members.   The other weakness of using a wiki is that two students cannot be using it concurrently.  Students need to be aware of the risks, and be informed users.  They also need to be made aware of copyright implications and how to reference material.  This is something that the teacher needs to regularly remind students about, and oversee as best they can. 

A wiki is a great collaboration tool which students can ‘own’.  It is socially interactive and aides construction of good productive pedagogy.

No comments:

Post a Comment