Should mobile phones be allowed in classrooms? The Mobile Phones wiki was my first participation in a wiki and overall, a positive experience! It was great to see and experience some of the theories we've been learning about - Social Constructivism, Connectivism, Bloom's Taxonomy, the Productive Pedagogies and TPACK – all applied in an actual learning scenario, where I was the learner!
I believe that the Social Constructivism learning theory was characterised in the wiki in many ways. Firstly, a "learning community" was encouraged to socially interact, which is a key aspect of Social Constructivism. Also, the activity was very well scaffolded by the lecturers in the following ways:
- by posing questions at each hat to guide our thinking and model the activity,
- by explaining the expected learning outcomes,
- by using a tool that suited the task (a wiki),
- by strongly encouraging collaboration and 'bouncing' ideas off one another,
- and internalisation of new knowledge is continuing to happen right now, through this reflective process!
Connectivism is the other learning theory that was evident in the Mobile Phones wiki. The lecturers encouraged students to not only add their own ideas but to explore further resources. I found an awesome PDF online that was very closely correlated to the learning theories and productive pedagogies that we've been learning about, AND it identified 20 ways to integrate mobile phones into a Second Language class! Here it is: 20 Ways to Use Mobile Phones in a Classroom. I feel that many of the suggestions could easily be applied to other subject areas in the Classroom. The article also discusses some problems that can arise when bringing mobile phones into the classroom however, it also offers suggestions that may help resolve the issues.
The following PMI table represents my reflection upon my own personal participation in the wiki:
Plus
|
Minus
|
Implications/Interesting
|
Everybody is encouraged to have a say therefore, lots of different perspectives can be gauged.
Scaffolding guided the discussion, so we knew what the lecturer wanted us to discuss, but still had the flexibility to add more.
De Bono’s hats encouraged broader thinking and to consider the issue from several different perspectives.
The wiki is a good record-keeping tool and it is great that you can go back to it any time as knowledge builds, and reflect on whether or not you still feel the same way.
The wiki allows you to bring in other sources of information e.g. Links to websites.
Participating in a wiki allows the student time to reflect upon their own ideas, and other people’s ideas before participating – it is self-paced.
No-one needs to be an expert in order to contribute. No-one is wrong or right. This encourages everyone to participate.
|
Once there are some ideas in the wiki, people might be influenced by them, or reluctant to add their own ideas, if they differ, as it is there in writing for everybody to see. If this happened then the wiki would not be a true reflection of the entire group.
Some people just say they agree instead of having a good think about it, and actually contributing new ideas.
I found the wiki itself a little cumbersome to use. It is easy to erase other student’s information, and I wonder if there is a risk of people doing this on purpose. If this has been done, on purpose or not, and no-one realises, that student might appear not to have participated and be assessed accordingly.
|
Reading someone else’s ideas can lead to new ideas and gives a different perspective and a deeper understanding of the issue.
If everyone participates honestly and openly, it is a fabulous tool for collaborating. It promotes higher order thinking skills.
It allows the teacher to scaffold the desired learning, yet allows the students to create their own journey.
It can result in people changing their original opinion as they are presented with new and different ideas. The result is a deeper knowledge and understanding of the subject.
Each student feels valued and empowered.
The wiki uses all 8 of the strategies within the productive pedagogies (See Note 1 below).
The wiki pertains to Bloom’s Taxonomy and TPACK.
|
The Mobile Phones wiki was an interesting exercise, and whilst I still haven’t made up my mind personally whether it is a good idea to encourage the use of mobile phones in classrooms or not, I have certainly been exposed to a whole array of different perspectives to consider. It was a clever way to demonstrate how a wiki can be used to facilitate great pedagogy!
_________________________________________________________________________
Note 1. Page 3 of our Learning Resources states that “The strategies within the productive pedagogies include:
1.) Facilitating deep knowledge through higher order thinking.
2.) Facilitating collaborative learning in which conversations are important
3.) Supporting students in knowing how they learn best
4.) Planning learning that is problem-based, and situated in real life contexts
5.) Is relevant to students, and connects to their background knowledge
6.) Supports learning that is owned, controlled and managed by students themselves
7.) Is socially supportive, engaging, and values cultural knowledge
8.) Is supportive of the development of active citizenship, and strong group identity.”
No comments:
Post a Comment